Top 5 Week: Frank Sinatra Songs

Who doesn't love Harry Connick, Jr.? He is a crooner and a swooner and I adore his music! Maybe this week's episode will be a little better than the last few weeks. I hope so. There aren't too many contestants, though, who I think will fit in well with a big band. But we shall see. Maybe someone will surprise us.

Aaron Kelly -- Fly Me to the Moon -- He seemed to struggle a little bit in the beginning. But I guess he got a little bit better toward the middle and end. It's kind of comical to watch him sing this style of music, though, because it definitely requires a certain swagger. Aaron definitely has zero swagger. But bless his little heart, he gave it a good shot.

Bonus Question: What was the funny story Casey shared about his friend back home?
Casey James -- Blue Skies -- Casey's voice is lacking a little, which is much easier to notice when he's performing without his guitar. I would say this performance was better than Aaron's, but definitely not something we would typically expect from a Top 5 contender on American Idol. But this is Season 9, so, all things considered, this was a decent performance.

Bonus Question: What large tattoo does Crystal sport across her back?
Crystal Bowersox -- Summer Wind -- Crystal is obviously the most seasoned and talented performer on the show this season. Her performance showcased that. I thought it was a little boring in the beginning, but the song became more interesting toward the middle and end. This was a nice performance of hers. I'm still a fan. My brother wanted me to say that Crystal looks like Julia Stiles. I put it in here because today is his birthday. And he's spending it watching American Idol and reading my blog over my shoulder.

Michael Lynche -- Writing this before he performs, I kind of think Michael could potentially shine with this style of music. The Way You Look Tonight -- For once Michael's cockiness has an opportunity to shine without becoming abrasive. His attitude carried across more as charm and swagger than conceit tonight and it definitely worked in his favor. I think Michael's was definitely the best performance of the night. And the truest to the Rat Pack stylings. The double-handed wave at the end was something I could have done without, though.

Lee Dewyze -- That's Life -- I love Michael Buble's version of this song. Lee was the second best tonight. It might be more because of the song than his vocals, though. Lee is primarily a really good gritty singer, but when his the song calls for a cleaner vocal, his voice just doesn't sound as good. But I loved hearing the song. The organ was a nice addition.
Bonus Question: What homework did Kara give Lee?

So who you do think will go home? Who do you think SHOULD go home? Answer the bonus questions and send me your predictions tomorrow before the show starts Wednesday!

*Tonight we'll be doing something a little different: The first person to answer will receive 20 bonus points, the second person will receive 15, the third person will receive 10, and the fourth person will receive 5. So get your answers in quickly!